A federal judge lets the NAACP’s Clean Air Act case against xAI proceed
TechCrunch and CNBC reported on Saturday that Judge Debra M. Brown denied xAI’s motion to dismiss. Earthjustice’s release, dated Friday, says the turbines support Colossus 2 in Southaven. The news accounts do not agree on whether the suit describes 27 turbines or at least 35. A preliminary injunction is still undecided.
Feature3 minIn-depth
Priya Shah3 min read
- xAI
- SpaceX
- Colossus
- Clean Air Act

Photo: Brandon Dill for The Washington Post / Getty Images, via TechCrunchSource page
A federal judge in Mississippi has denied xAI’s motion to dismiss a Clean Air Act lawsuit brought by the NAACP, TechCrunch, CNBC, and Earthjustice reported. Anthony Ha’s TechCrunch story is timestamped 2:17 p.m. Pacific time on Saturday, 10:17 p.m. in Amsterdam. Lora Kolodny’s CNBC story was published at 2:56 p.m. Eastern and updated at 4:12 p.m. She writes that the opinion was released late Friday. Earthjustice’s release is dated 30 October and says the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Mississippi denied the motion on Friday. TechCrunch says it asked SpaceX for comment. CNBC says SpaceX did not immediately respond.
The case was filed in April. Earthjustice says the Southern Environmental Law Center and Earthjustice represent the NAACP, and that the suit targets an unpermitted power plant supporting the Colossus 2 data center. TechCrunch describes turbines at the Colossus site outside Memphis. CNBC says the turbines are in Southaven, Mississippi, and that they power data centers in Greater Memphis. The three accounts are the same lawsuit. They do not use the same site name.
Because the plaintiffs have statutory standing under the Clean Air Act, because the combustion turbines are not ‘mobile sources’ under Mississippi’s [State Implementation Plan], and because the citizen suit provision does not violate Article II of the Constitution or the private nondelegation doctrine, the plaintiffs’ claims will proceed.
— Judge Debra M. Brown, as quoted by TechCrunch and CNBC. The brackets are TechCrunch’s.
A mobile-source claim, and two counts of the turbines
xAI’s motion, as both TechCrunch and CNBC describe it, argued that the turbines were exempt because the company called them mobile, that the plaintiffs lacked standing, and that this kind of citizen suit is unconstitutional. On the constitutional point, TechCrunch quotes Judge Brown writing that citizen-suit plaintiffs sue on their own behalf, in their own name, and seek penalties that redress harm to themselves, so they are not exercising the federal government’s executive power. Earthjustice quotes a different sentence on the exemption: because the plant is not a mobile source under the federal regulations, it was not, and is not, exempt from permitting.
The number of turbines is not the same in the two news accounts. TechCrunch quotes the Southern Environmental Law Center saying the company had “installed and operated at least 35 combustion turbines and other sources of air pollution at the Colossus site” without the necessary preconstruction or operating permits. CNBC says the suit alleges that between August and December 2025, xAI and its subsidiary MZX Tech installed and operated 27 gas turbines in Southaven “without an air permit or regard for the health and safety of people living nearby.” Neither story explains the gap between 27 and at least 35.
Earthjustice says the turbines can emit more than 5,000 tons of smog-forming nitrogen oxides, 400 tons of fine particulate matter, and 47 tons of formaldehyde a year, and it ties those pollutants to asthma, heart disease, respiratory illness, cancer, and premature death. Those figures are the organization’s, for what the turbines can emit. They are not a finding the Saturday news stories attribute to the judge. The same release says the court has not yet ruled on the NAACP’s motion for a preliminary injunction.
A Justice Department motion, already denied
All three accounts say a similar motion from the Department of Justice failed earlier. CNBC puts that ruling about two weeks before Saturday’s story. TechCrunch says earlier this month. Earthjustice says the xAI ruling came shortly after the court denied the department’s motion. Abre’ Conner, the NAACP’s director of environmental and climate justice, said in the Earthjustice release that the decision was another victory, that the courts have rejected attempts by xAI and the department to dismiss the case, and that xAI cannot operate gas turbines without the required permits. TechCrunch carried a shorter version of that statement on Saturday and spelled the surname Connor.
Our position has been clear: xAI cannot operate gas turbines without the required permits. Now that the motion to dismiss has been denied, we look forward to continuing to defend our position in court.
— Abre’ Conner, NAACP director of environmental and climate justice, in Earthjustice’s 30 October release


